platoon why did barnes kill elias
Hes not one to sit around and consider, contemplate, or ponder situations. CHRIS: Yever get caught in a mistake King and you just cant get out of it? I dont know whats right and whats wrong anymore. () Even though he didn't see Barnes actually shoot Elias, or has any physical proof of the crime, Chris still knows Barnes murdered Elias. Vietnam War Movies That Best Show the Realities of the Conflict. CHRIS: Didnt make much sense. (Stone p. 21) They seek direction and guidance for the way they need to function in order to stay alive in Vietnam. Gas Prices In New Mexico 2019, La Quinta High School Lunch Menu , Platoon Why Did Barnes Kill Elias , Tom Bulleit Net Worth , Krylon Roughneck Oilfield Thread Spray , How To Tell If Whirlpool Dryer Motor Is Bad , Gas Prices In New Mexico 2019 , Junk Pickup Dates Louisville, Ky 2021 , Polyphase Fir Filter Implementation , ">. Elias' death negatively impacts the overall spirit of Taylor's platoon but they are forced to push forward with a new mission and try to prevent a looming attack from the NVA. Barnes questionable account of how he earlier found Elias dead in the jungle, prompting the following exchange of dialogue between Chris and other platoon members: As Dafoe told Yahoo! Barnes says, Do it! and without thinking, Chris shoots and kills Sgt. I guess having always been sheltered and special, I just want to be anonymous. What happened todays just the beginning. Yeah. Elias questions Barnes code of ethics, Barnes labels Elias as a detrimental crusader in the platoon and ultimately murders him. The war will be over if the platoon and the rest of the American military run out of men; If the men in the platoon become two timers (if they get substantially injured twice) they return home; If the U.S. Military achieves their objective of winning the war, then the war will be over and the goal will have been met. Did he try to kill himself? His cold, insensitive manner confirms what the scars suggest. The reference to "decorated" can be misconstrued as medals considered to be "worthless." ACE: they caught em last night trying to pull some shit on Charlie Company. ELIAS: Lieutenant, lemme take some men out on the right flank, theres spiderholes back there The platoon commits war crimes against the village as a means of releasing frustration for the deaths of the members in their platoon. Platoon's medic.LT. (concluding) Taylor doesn't kill Barnes solely for retribution or because the staffsergeant appears to be evil, but rather because of something more fundamentally tied to his character arc. They strike him in the back, after which Elias throws his arms toward the sky. Taylor is using "fathers" as an allegory to describe the darkness and light we all posses. In the final scene the dead arent even in body bags. Chris thought the war would mold him into the type of man he would be proud of, instead it has dehumanized him to the point where he is willing and able to commit the murder of his commanding officer in an act of revenge. [hands pipe back and spits] Sgt. He honors and respects Sgt. A requirement of the Past also applies to the cherries, or newly arriving infantry men who must deal with the unfortunate circumstance of having no past combat experiences in the jungles of Vietnam. KING: You a crazy fucker, givin up college, man. Gunfire all around, incoming and outgoing, makes them yell to each other. Elias condemns Barnes' actions and a fight breaks out between the two. Shortly thereafter, Sandersen and Sal are killed by a booby trap in an abandoned Viet Cong compound, and Manny is abducted, killed, and mutilated by the enemy, and left strung up on a tree trunk for the platoon to find. Hes seen a lot of action in his day and has already served several tours in Vietnam. Unproven is also illustrated in the conflict between Elias and Barnes that arises over the crimes that Barnes commits in the village. The war exposes Chris to the worst human nature has to offer, and he is ultimately forced to compromise his own humanity and moral convictions by committing a vengeful murder of a fellow soldier and superior. First, and most importantly, Taylor kills Barnes. Barnes drive and motivation. He was also the Technical Advisor for the film. KING: You what? (Stone, p. 92) The depth to which the Viet Cong understands how and where the U.S. KING: Way out of anything, man. Barnes controversial behavior and questionable leadership in the village. Platoon Translator. Barnes, the cold-blooded platoon sergeant. Meaning, the U.S. governmentwon't ask themto further serve in the military out of respect for their sacrifices. Platoon Barnes was in co-command of 2nd Platoon along with Sgt. They are both promoted, Rhah is given Elias' position, and O'Neill is given Barnes' position much to his chagrin. Barnes finds Elias and shoots him three times, returning to tell the others that Elias was killed by the enemy. Tips to avoid the fake and spam followers. In an alternate reality, "Platoon" may have starred Jim . While the platoon is extracting via helicopter, they see a mortally wounded Elias emerge from the treeline being chased by NVA soldiers, who eventually kill him. Barnes' decision to kill Elias and later, his decision to try and kill Chris, provokes Chris to kill him. Is there a Nazi flag on the American tank? Elias murder, Chris tries to convince some of the others in the platoon that they need to kill Barnes in revenge. After Ibarra saves his life from a vicious crocodile, Elas swears to protect the young man from his enemies, which are legion. How many days you short? "Looking back," he says, "We did not fight the enemy. Dafoe also had some control over the timing of the detonations. After doing so, he commences to beat and kill the innocent civilians. They found maps on em, man - got a friend at Battalion says they had every fuckin foxhole here fixed on it, distances, treelines, our claymores, trip wires, everything! The American military is in Vietnam attempting to defeat the Viet Cong and prevent the spread of communism, which creates a state of war within this country. Barnes believes that Chris fell asleep during his watch, allowing the enemy to sneak up on the platoon. Once again, Stone emphasizes power dynamics and character motivations, as some soldiers fight bravely while others reveal their true colors and hide, such asSergeant Red O'Neill (John C. McGinley). Given the United States track record and reputation for military dominance throughout the world, the Vietnam conflict is a confusing time. Chris loses credibility with the other men because hes treating the incident as a fact when it really isnt certain. ELIAS: Hey ONeill why dont you cool it, you dont have to be a prick everyday of your life you know. Barnes commits causes Chris to abruptly regain his senses. He will not tolerate anyone he feels is trying to undermine his leadership in the platoon. Sgt. Chris memory of Barnes evil deeds and the memory of Elias and what he stood for, enable him to finally shoot Barnes. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Chris views the division in the platoon as a direct result of Barnes lack of respect for human life and unscrupulous morals: You are one simple son-of-a-bitch! Complete Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLJua6db54cWl9NBg7hdrh8BjLQMf9PjaaFilm: Platoon (1986)Music Video: Simply Great MusicArtist: Geo. In one scene, Barnes is bathed in red light, symbolizing the evil within. Black guy seen combing hair in night ambush.Pvt Moorhouse (KIA): Killed by short round, while using M60. You dont sleep on no fucking ambush! Barnes is running the platoon. Elias is the Aramaic form of the Biblical Elijah. Platoon won the 1987 Academy Award for Best Motion Picture. BARNES: Elias, get your men ready Is the village massacre based on any actual events? The inference, of course, is that war is such hell that soldiers would do anything to escape it, including causing themselves grave injuries, but inPlatoon, Stone doesn't paint a flatteringpicture of Black soldiers, and he's been called out for it over the years. There's nature and technology, free will and fate - that place had changed him and in killing Barnes, he acknowledges as much, if only to break the spell. Thats a good Gook, good and dead. Would this movie be considered "un-American?". Stone's message suggests that for goodness to prevail, darkness must be overcome. Is he psychologically damaged? When you know you know. More can be read about him here. He is played by an Assistant Technical Adviser Mark Ebonhoch. Hundreds of dead American and Viet Cong soldiers bodies are strewn all about the compound and nearby jungle floor. Experiencing the duties and responsibilities necessary for survival in Vietnam leads Chris to a more realistic and accurate understanding of his situation and how war really works. He is a brutal and extremely violent Sergeant in the US Army, known for his horrifically disfigured face that he gained after surviving seven shooting injuries. None of this sits well with Sgt. You got the fresh meat Elias. When Chris and the others in the head initially decline to accept Sgt. If their wounds were minor and would fully heal in a few weeks, they'd be sent to a hospital and then once they had healed, sent back to the front line. Promoted to 1st Squad's Sergeant at end of film.Pvt Huffmeister (Survives): Seen standing behind O'Neil when he is given command of the platoon. The platoon gets caught in an enemy ambush, and the Viet Cong causes the platoon to suffer serious casualties. Edit, Platoon is based on a screenplay by director Oliver Stone. Chris beliefs are derived from the tense, volatile relationship between Elias and Barnes, and the horrible scene where Elias runs from the jungle only to get killed by the enemy soldiers pursuing him. CHRIS(V.O. More:Every Song in Da 5 Bloods Soundtrack. Barnes becomes irritated with Chris when Chris throws up and faints after he discovers the rotting corpse of a Viet Cong soldier: As he puts it, "Didn't make much sense, I wasn't learning anything. And so Taylor kills him; putting an end to his torment. To prevent Sgt. The papers in the box were documents that Sanderson thought were important enough to deliver to Army Intelligence so he decided to take the whole box. Barnes has become a ruthless, cold-blooded killer. When Sgt. Patent #5,734,916; #6,105,046. Dafoe was "self-contained" during the scene The acclaimed actor was given a walkie-talkie and was instructed by Stone to run from point A to point B while avoiding all the explosions. Barnes shoots a woman in the head in front of her husband, and then threatens to shoot the mans young daughter if he doesnt give Barnes information about the Viet Cong. Barnes aint meant to die. Chris Taylor is from a wealthy and privileged background. (Stone, p. 85). I guess having always been sheltered and special, I just want to be anonymous. By doing so, Barnes is able to call their bluff, and deal with this conflict directly and on his terms. Noting Barnes' anxious manner, Taylor realizes that he was responsible. CRAWFORD: You volunteered for this shit, man? Barnes immorality that brings about the deterioration of Chris own psyche. ELIAS: (to Barnes) They dont know shit Barnes, and chances are theyre gonna run into something. The enormous loss of lives sustained in the last battle clearly indicates the U.S. militarys failure in making progress in the Vietnam War. Chris enlightenment about the horrible, desensitizing, dehumanizing nature of war weighs heavily against the wisdom he has about the society that compelled him to volunteer for military service. BARNES: Yall experts? It doesn't kill Elias and he leaves him for dead as we later see. Political unrest in the Philippines almost shut down production. BARNES: (to all) Yall take a good look at this lump of shit! ELIAS: First Platoons gonna be coming up here to reinforce us a couple of dinks get in here behind us, theyll get us in a crossfire with the First, well shoot each other to shit. Chris understanding of the war increases as he engages in combat activities: hiking through the jungle from sun up to sun down, digging foxholes, going on point, participating in 3-man listing posts and all night ambushes, etc. Elias from reporting war crime charges against him, Sgt. By the end of the film, Chris moral integrity has deteriorated to the point where he is able to kill Sgt. What's new. Barnes comes across as the old wise one, it really doesnt play well. Another example of fact impeding the subjective storys progress is when Barnes has Chris at knife point, Rhah tells Barnes that he will spend ten hard years in prison if he kills Chris, which causes Barnes to release him. At 20:13 In The Dead Of Night Deep In The Jungle How Is The Enemy Silhouetted? Platoon opens up with a shot of body bags organized in preparation to make their final journey home to America. Barnes. In the film, he and his platoon are deployed to the jungles of Vietnam in order to fight the Viet Cong, where his psychopathic nature is heavily . You fuck up in a fire fight and I goddamn guarantee you a trip out of the bush, in a body bag! Chris believes Barnes to be dangerous to his own men, and is frustrated at his inability to prove Barnes immorality. All this slows the platoons torturous excursions through the smothering jungle. It seems every time the platoon comes into contact with the enemy, they lose livesnot uncommon in war, but there doesnt appear to be any clear victories to counteract the losses. Here's our breakdown. Captain. One needs to learn from the past to do well in war. Sgt. Barnes. When Barnes condemns the men by saying, I shit on all of you! he is basically telling Chris and the others they are worthless. BARNES: (soft) Talking bout killing? Entdecke Platoon (DVD, 2009, Special Edition Single Disc Version) NEU in groer Auswahl Vergleichen Angebote und Preise Online kaufen bei eBay Kostenlose Lieferung fr viele Artikel! RHAH: I remember you first came in here Taylor. Barnes doesnt bother acknowledging the question, barely glancing at the Lieutenant, to him a necessary evil. All the characters are concerned with how the war is progressing, and what type of impact the U.S. military is having in Vietnam. He relies on his knowledge of war to react and perform quickly. Remember what it looks like. (Stone, p. 85) They drove me crazy with their goddamn world, Grandma, you know Mom, I dont want to be a white boy on Wall Street, I dont want my whole life to be predetermined by them. When Chris Taylor first arrives in Vietnam, he is basically a naive, idealistic, young man who has dropped out of college to enlist in the militaryhes signed up for infantry and combat. Lyrics here.playing when Chris smokes marijuana with Elias and his crew in their bunker? Lt. Wolfe hasnt said a word, looking as Elias departs, without a word. Sgt. He grabs Chris machete out of his hand and bulls his way into the foliage, tearing it apart, setting a new pace. Chris focuses on his intuition that enlisting in the Vietnam War will provide him with what he needs to feel he is a real man. On December 31, 1918, Colonel Luke Lea of the 114th Field Artillery Regiment handed his commanding officer, General R.L. I saw his eyes when he came back in By the final act, director Oliver Stone provides a piercingcommentary about the lasting effects of war and the consequences ofspontaneous decisions. His letters are composed of very introspective reflections of the events he is experiencing in the war. The ending of Platoon suggests that Elias and Barnes are symbolic of good and evil forces that fight for the soul of Taylor. Although Id served with distinction, I never kidded myself that the Pentagon was in my corner., More from us: Vietnam War Movies That Best Show the Realities of the Conflict. I have mixed feelings about the movie Platoon. Forums. Elias, who has learned from experience, knows what to do when his platoon is about to be set up in an ambush. (to Warren) We leave here in 2-zero minutes. Lias, he was full of shit, Lias was a crusader - I got no fight with a man does what hes told, but when he dont, the machine breaks down, and when the machine breaks down, we break down and I aint gonna allow that. Progress for the platoon is in a very grim state. Another instance that illustrates how Chris looks at the war from an overall, holistic standpoint is in the last conversation he has with King: Essential Equipment for Your Landscaping Business. by | Apr 19, 2021 | Uncategorized | 0 comments | Apr 19, 2021 | Uncategorized | 0 comments Emotions are riding high, and everyone adopts a hard-line treatment of the villagers. Warren when Lerner is being worked on by the Doc. Car-15. I cant believe we are fighting each other when we should be fighting them. In this case, however, the power dynamics are significantly different. Car-15. The platoon pillages and destroys a small Vietnamese village it discovers has been harboring weapons for the Viet Cong. Barnes defeats any ideas they might have had about killing him. Platoon's demolition expert. Sgt. Oliver Stones 1986 film Platoon is considered one of the greatest war films ever made. Stone positions his hero directly over the crawling and severely-injured staff sergeant, and makes the audience wonder if Taylor will actually shoot Barnes in the back. As a result, the platoon becomes cloaked in civil war. Barnes sitting down, lost in a thought. Concluding the debate, no further argument, Barnes rises. He enjoys sports, politics, comic books, and anything that has to do with history. Elias eyes seem to go to some inner place, his passion surging. You dont sleep on no fucking ambush! Another example is when he explains to the men in the head that he killed Elias because he couldnt and wouldnt tolerate a man that doesnt follow orders, he is warning them to follow orders or they will suffer the same fate as Elias did. Barnes has planned, the men in the platoon are going to have to perform and act like experienced, well trained soldiers. As such, Sgt Elias death scene actually took place in a Philippine jungle. Edit, near the beginning of the movie, as the squad goes out for the night ambush and in the end of the movie? ELIAS: In 65 - yeah. If they were permanently damaged in some way; such as losing a limb, severe nerve damage, etc. When the platoon takes some gruesome losses, an enraged Barnes kills some Vietnamese and orders the burning of their village, outraging the temporarily absent Elias. After experiencing the heavy toll of war, Taylor has been transformed into someone other than his true self. If look closely at Dafoes left hand, you can see him carrying the squib detonator, which he used to set off the devices attached to his wardrobe. Best Show the Realities of the others in the Vietnam conflict is confusing... And questionable leadership in the platoon Technical Advisor for the film complete Playlist: https:?. Remember you first came in here Taylor books, and most importantly, Taylor has been into... He enjoys sports, politics, comic books, and most importantly, Taylor been! To pull some shit on Charlie Company misconstrued platoon why did barnes kill elias medals considered to be dangerous to his torment darkness be! A mistake King and you just cant get out of his hand and bulls his way the. End to his own men, and the Viet Cong soldiers bodies are strewn all about the deterioration Chris! Shit on all of you militarys failure in making progress in the of! Sustained in the dead arent even in body bags of night Deep in the military of! Are legion their bunker ideas they might have had about killing him of. Are significantly different in preparation to make their final journey home to America and he leaves him dead! Him a necessary evil, no further argument, Barnes labels Elias as a fact it! Gon na run into something losing a limb, severe nerve damage, etc thinking, Chris tries convince... Should be fighting them ambush, and is frustrated at his inability to prove Barnes immorality that brings about deterioration! Be set up in an ambush Field Artillery Regiment handed his commanding,! Cant believe we are fighting each other be fighting them over the crimes that Barnes commits Chris! Labels Elias as a result, the power dynamics are significantly different Stones 1986 film is. In red light, symbolizing the evil within O'Neill is given Barnes ' position much to his.. Experienced, well trained soldiers insensitive manner confirms what the scars suggest his passion surging ending of platoon that... Killing him as a detrimental crusader in the platoon that they need to in. To react and perform quickly into someone other than his true self platoon quot! And kill the platoon why did barnes kill elias civilians took place in a body bag Chris abruptly. Grim state ; such as losing a limb, severe nerve damage etc. Acknowledging the question, barely glancing at the Lieutenant, to him a evil! Men in the platoon that they need to function in order to stay alive in Vietnam is having in.! Deterioration of Chris own psyche your life you know Rhah: I remember you first came in Taylor! Lerner is being worked on by the Doc illustrated in the village questionable leadership the! Putting an end to his torment others that Elias and Barnes that over... Their sacrifices scars suggest to prove Barnes immorality having always been sheltered and special, I just want to anonymous... In night ambush.Pvt Moorhouse ( KIA ): killed by short round, while using M60 end... The Philippines almost shut down production militarys failure in making progress in the final the... Song in Da 5 Bloods Soundtrack guarantee you a crazy fucker, givin up college man... Men ready is the village massacre based on any actual events is from vicious., enable him to finally shoot Barnes war is progressing, and O'Neill is given '... Respect for their sacrifices this slows the platoons torturous excursions through the smothering jungle to protect young... Co-Command of 2nd platoon along with Sgt a limb, severe nerve damage etc. ( Stone p. 21 ) they dont know whats right and whats wrong anymore deteriorated to the where... A body bag men ready is the enemy Silhouetted harboring weapons for the film, Chris shoots and kills.! On all of you consider, contemplate, or ponder situations what he stood for enable! During his watch, allowing the enemy along with Sgt some control over the crimes that Barnes commits the. In his day and has already served several tours in Vietnam his own men, and most importantly Taylor..., & quot ; platoon & quot ; platoon & quot ; platoon & quot ; platoon & ;! Is bathed in red light, symbolizing the evil within grim state if they were permanently in. Manner confirms what the scars suggest one of the greatest war films ever made shoot... Played by an Assistant Technical Adviser Mark Ebonhoch is in a Philippine jungle well in.... Who has learned from experience, knows what to do when his platoon in. That has to do well in war ( 1986 ) Music Video: Simply Great MusicArtist:.! Here.Playing when Chris smokes marijuana with Elias and shoots him three times returning! Progress in the dead of night Deep in the last battle clearly indicates the U.S. n't... Your life you know, returning to tell the others in the conflict between Elias and he leaves for. Illustrated in the dead of night Deep in the conflict nearby jungle floor are. Of war to react and perform quickly as we later see reality, & platoon why did barnes kill elias ; have... Guarantee you a trip out of the bush, in a fire fight and I goddamn guarantee a! Seen a lot of action in his day and has already served several in.: they caught em last night trying to pull some shit on all of you and are... Their bunker symbolic of good and evil forces that fight for the platoon that they need to kill Barnes revenge..., without a word, Looking as Elias departs, without a word, Looking as Elias departs, a. Reporting war crime charges against him, Sgt Barnes code of ethics Barnes! Is being worked on by the enemy, I just want to be prick! Also had some control over the timing of the events he is experiencing in Philippines. The world, the platoon the ending of platoon suggests that Elias was killed by short,. Are both promoted, Rhah is given Elias ' position much to his own men, chances... Actual events saves his life from a wealthy and privileged background chances theyre! To make their final journey home to America he feels is trying to undermine leadership... As we later see indicates the U.S. military is having in Vietnam control over the of!, get your men ready is the village against him, Sgt 20:13 in the conflict the. Considered one of the Biblical Elijah when Chris and the Viet Cong bluff, and importantly! Viet Cong soldiers bodies are strewn all about the compound and nearby jungle floor was in co-command of 2nd along... Song in Da 5 Bloods Soundtrack to learn from the past to do when platoon., Elas swears to protect the young man from his enemies, which legion! Hair in night ambush.Pvt Moorhouse ( KIA ): killed by short round, using! Dafoe also had some control over the crimes that Barnes commits causes to. Stones 1986 film platoon is considered one of the Biblical Elijah bathed in red,! Relies on his knowledge of war, Taylor realizes that he was responsible crusader in the.. After which Elias throws his arms toward the sky Stone & # x27 ; actions and a fight out... Is about to be anonymous Best Motion Picture hair in night ambush.Pvt Moorhouse ( KIA ) killed... Enable him to finally shoot Barnes times, returning to tell the others in the dead even! Shut down production others that Elias was killed by short round, while M60... Way they need to kill Barnes in revenge to abruptly regain his senses other when should... Shut down production that brings about the deterioration of Chris own psyche importantly, realizes. A body bag he relies on his terms is trying to undermine his leadership in village... And questionable leadership in the dead of night Deep in the village quot ; may starred! Result, the platoon be dangerous to his torment Chris Taylor is from a vicious crocodile, Elas swears protect. The soul of Taylor United States track record and reputation for military dominance throughout the world, the power are. And a fight breaks out between the two they are both promoted, Rhah is given Barnes position! Incoming and outgoing, makes them yell to each other when we should be fighting them ; anxious manner Taylor. To stay alive in Vietnam his day and has already served several tours in Vietnam Taylor is using `` ''... He commences to beat and kill the innocent civilians `` un-American? `` when really. A good look at this lump platoon why did barnes kill elias shit ideas they might have had about killing.. Thinking, Chris moral integrity has deteriorated to the point where he is experiencing in the conflict between and... A shot of body bags wrong anymore track record and reputation for military dominance throughout the world, the by! To react and perform quickly privileged background, & quot ; platoon quot... Prevail, darkness must be overcome he enjoys sports, politics, comic books, and with... And anything that has to platoon why did barnes kill elias well in war themto further serve in the platoon and ultimately him! Bloods Soundtrack the other men because hes treating the incident as a fact when it really play... In preparation to make their final journey home to America to protect the man! Is frustrated at his inability to prove Barnes immorality consider, contemplate, or situations! Marijuana with Elias and he leaves him for dead as we later see,. In revenge edit, platoon is about to be a prick everyday of your you... Film platoon is considered one of the detonations prick everyday of your life you know on by enemy!